Wednesday, October 26, 2016 31 Comments
Brain-Change vs. Compensation
TIME is of the Essence
© Madelyn Griffith-Haynie, CTP, CMC, ACT, MCC, SCAC
from the Self-Help Series – Part I
Arguing with YouTube
I have been watching a lot of brain-based TED Talks of late – talks from notables like the following:
- Daniel Amen on the importance of brain health
- Barbara Arrowsmith Young on overcoming brain-based problem through cognitive exercises
- Max Cynader on how plasticity can be improved
I added links to those videos above so you can click to watch them too.
Their Advice for Us
Each of them hopes to direct the focus of the world to healing the problem rather than working at the level of symptoms.
That makes A LOT of sense, right?
I LIKE these experts, and applaud their efforts.
I have known about the things they espouse for many years now,
and I think each is a great idea.
HOWEVER, something about each of their talks left me with a sense that something was off, or missing — or that, in the way they came up with their advised solutions, they devalued or overlooked a point of view that was important.
It took me a bit of noodling, but I finally figured out what was bugging me.
- The advice was presented in an either/or, better/worse, black and white fashion that, in some subtle manner, left me with an uneasy feeling. I was left with an impression that they each believed that their way of working was the best way for ALL individuals to proceed — and that we would be somehow foolish to approach finding a solution to compensate for our challenges instead of “fixing” the root cause.
- They seemed oblivious to the reality that, for a great many of us, some of their solutions are absolutely out of reach financially (Do you have any idea how much it costs to get a brain scan for diagnostic purposes, for example?)
- They left out the TIME factor altogether – and didn’t quite explain who was going to support us while we set about changing our brains by getting more sleep, changing our diets for optimal brain health and healing, or working through exercises that will improve short term memory (for example).
Few of us can afford to take a year or more OFF while we take advantage of the miracle of neuroplasticity to give our brains a fighting chance at “normalizing.”